
Are you giggling?
Girl Talk (published by Five Star Publications) is written by Gigi Garner. Her dad is James Garner.
The back cover says:
"Something special happens when women get together and talk-confidences are shared, help and support given, all in the name of sisterhood and friendship - and with Girl Talk in your hand, you're never far from a trusted friend. Girl Talk brings well over 100 caring women into your life in including famous personalities like Sally Struthers, Lucie Arnaz, Joan and Melissa Rivers, Shari Belafonte, Jamie Lee Curstus and Naomi Judd. With Girl Talk, the wisdom of female attorneys, heads of corporations, teachers, actors, journalists, bankers, artists, doctors and more is at your fingertips."
The book is filled with short tidbits of "wisdom" from women like the ones described above.
Some of the advice was helpful. I liked the cleaning tips and general "girlfriend" beauty suggestions, solutions on the go, etc.
I enjoyed this one story the most:
"Right after my husband and I were married we seemed to really be struggling financially. Everything seemed so hard and expensive! We had an awful time trying to make ends meet month to month. We were both so stressed out and this was not helpful in a new marriage. One day, I went down to the bottom of the hill to pay our landlord. Our landlord is a sweet little eighty-five year old lady. I think she recognized the look of stress on my face as I handed her our last dime. She was kind enough to offer some grandmotherly advice that I will never forget: "Dear, whenever you get upset about money, remember that when you get to be my age, none of this will matter anymore. I think of the times when my husband and I struggled when we were young and looking back, it was a waste of time to worry. Everything always has a way of turning out all right. Think about the future and don't worry your present strife."
As a lover of mentoring, I was blessed by the words of that older woman. What treasure.
Honestly, the rest of Girl Talk did not hold my attention. The book retails for $15.95. I think that's very expensive for this soft-cover book.
I appreciate the author's heart. I agree that wonderful things happen when women share their lives with one another. Since this book was not from a Christian perspective, as a believer I kept reminding myself that things like cleaning tips are fun, but this book was labeling the worldly messages it contained about life and how to live it as "wisdom."
I could not relate to this book hardly at all. Notice that nowhere in the list of accomplishments of women from the back cover does it mention "wife" or "mother."
As a wife and mother, the things that most of these career women had to say about life and values were not things that spoke to me or encouraged me. We simply don't value the same things (or maybe we do, but those things were not included in the book).
I didn't want to be a jerk going into reading the book, but there is this part of me that is ever skeptical of things that claim to be "wise" and full of "wisdom."
James 3:13-18
Who is wise and understanding among you? Let him show it by his good life, by deeds done in the humility that comes from wisdom. But if you harbor bitter envy and selfish ambition in your hearts, do not boast about it or deny the truth. Such "wisdom" does not come down from heaven but is earthly, unspiritual, of the devil. For where you have envy and selfish ambition, there you find disorder and every evil practice.
But the wisdom that comes from heaven is first of all pure; then peace-loving, considerate, submissive, full of mercy and good fruit, impartial and sincere. Peacemakers who sow in peace raise a harvest of righteousness.
I appreciated what the women in this book had to say, but bottom line...I don't know them. God says that there is a way to know if people are wise. You tell by the way they live their lives. Are their lives filled with purity, mercy and good fruit? Are they considerate and submissive? Are they peacemakers?I don't know the condition of these women's homes or their marriages. I have no idea if their children have been loved or neglected. I have no idea if these women will be 85 years old like that lady in the story above and look back on their life and see a beautiful legacy of love and life being passed on to the next generation or if they will look back and see nothing but huge piles of regret.
Did they build or destroy? I have no way of knowing that from this book, so it was hard to let their words truly speak to me or take those words and label them "wisdom."
One time I was at a conference and heard a speaker say, "As believers, the greatest influences in our lives better be Godly ones."
I sat there and thought of who was influencing me as a woman. Lots of the people I could think of at the time were celebrities, or women I only knew from far off. I had no idea what their lives looked like or if they loved God. I knew some of them didn't. And yet I was letting their thoughts...what they thought was important shape my life and decisions I was making.
I was a fool.
Our time is limited as women, wives and mothers. God tells us to live purposefully, to take advantage of every opportunity. He clearly teaches in Titus 2 that mentoring is important, that we learn great things from older, wiser women.
I am thankful for the opportunity to review this book, but I pray over all of the women reading this post that we would be striving to be the women God has created us to be. I pray we are choosing to build...growing in wisdom...in grace...in good fruit...in mercy...in peace making.
I pray that God's Word is where we look for wisdom, that we value mentoring and that we have women in our lives teaching us the things found in Titus 2.
I pray that the people we are allowing to influence us are Godly. It's always fun to listen to women when they get together and talk. I love that. I enjoyed reading some of the stories in this book. However, I hope that we never take what someone says...their advice...or "wisdom" without making sure that person truly is wise according to God's Word.
With that said, I think if you are a woman looking for a book to speak truth and encouragement over your life, there are lots of other great books out there that are filled with rich wisdom from older, wiser, women whose lives have been tested (Elizabeth Elliot, Carolyn Mahaney, Martha Peace).
This is a Mama Buzz review. The product was provided by Five Star Publications for this review.







