Unraveling the web of Spain's Sweatshops (from CNN)
If you're new to this whole idea, this is a great, recent article that describes some of the conditions people are living in who make our clothing. Eye opening.
Many of you may be asking, "Well, I know sweat shops are not ideal, but what if those sweat shops close down? Then what will people do?" This is a great question. Smarty pants people who are doing this stuff for a living are asking these same questions.
Where Sweatshops Are a Dream from The New York Times
Kristoff, one of my favorite humanitarians and author of one of my favorite books, Half the Sky argues for more sweat shops. To be fair, I wanted to include his opinion.
Why Jeffrey Sachs is Wrong about Sweat Shops from Mail and Guardian Online.
This is another smarty pants article that argues against what people like Kristoff are saying. Interesting. I asked my brainiac business friend about this article and he had some great things to say. Maybe I can get him to write up his thoughts.
Have we mentioned that we're not experts in any of this? We're not economists, we're not attacking any one political party, and we'd never claim that solving poverty-related problems are easy. Poverty is complex. We live in a country where we see this firsthand. There are no easy answers.
What we are asking ourselves are these questions: "How can we stand before the Lord with clean hearts as we consider the poor...particularly the laborer?" "How can we ensure, to the best of our abilities, that we did not deny the laborer their wages for the products we purchase?" "In the words of Mother Theresa, how can we live simply so others can simply live?"
This means, even though we respect a lot of what Kristoff (author of Half the Sky) has to say about poverty, women's rights, and slavery, as believers who desperately want to live out God's heart towards the poor, we can't agree that the answer to poverty is more sweat shops. We'd never go so far as to say the answer to poverty is consumer responsibility. Poverty is vast and complex. We can dress it up all we want, but I think if we're honest, we can all agree that the human heart, and our inherent greed is one of the biggest driving forces behind poverty. Maybe that's why Jesus talked so much about the poor and our response to them.
We want to be honest about our own sinful hearts as a couple, and so what we can do is ask ourselves some hard questions about our constant pull towards materialism, and then try to wisely decipher how to shop in a more responsible way. We can ask the church, the very people God has commanded to live out His heart of justice towards the poor and oppressed what we're doing to fight this injustice.
For those of you asking for some resources to use when deciding how to shop, I'll hopefully be talking more about this soon. I was going to post the resources later, but I've gotten several emails and a couple comments from women who are about to go insane if they don't know how to start making some progress in this area A-sap. You girls are ferocious, justice-lovers.
One of my favorite resources is "The Better World Shopping Guide." The author, and researcher, Dr. Ellis is allowing us to give one away. Stay tuned!
"Most people know that Jesus came to bring forgiveness and grace.
Less well known is the Biblical teaching that a true experience of the grace of Jesus Christ
inevitably motivates a man or woman to seek justice in the world."
-- Generous Justice by Tim Keller
13 comments:
The better world shopping guide is my go-to! You can actually find all the pertinent information at http://www.betterworldshopper.org/. Also: thrift stores!!!!!!!!! I haven't bought anything (besides unmentionables and a baby outfit or two) new in over 2 years!
Wow! "Krisindanielle" 2 years?! That is awesome! and amazing!
For readers in the Houston/Pearland area...Restyle Pearland. Cute womens consignment clothes.
Thank you Heather for this reminder! A couple of years ago (when you first wrote about all this) I was fired up, but in America, where I'm so detached from it I forget so quickly. Yesterday I spent quite a bit at Old Navy without even a second thought about how it got there...and so cheaply...
Thank you for this introduction of the issues! I was actually thinking of Kristoff's article when I read the previous post--not that his opinions are any justification for the idol of materialism nor does he mean them to be. Just wrestling with these ideas along with everyone else, I suppose.
I would encourage you also to read The Tragedy of American Compassion by Marvin Olasky. He makes a great case for why fair trade is not in the best interests of the farmer/producer.
I'm almost done with it and should probably read it again, but it's a a great resource for putting compassion in the right terms with what is best Biblically (and economically).
thank you so much for posting this. we have been wrestling with this very issue as we are due with our fourth child in october and gave everything we owned (baby related) away. i decided to try to buy everything i can american-made/free trade or second hand. a friend recently recommended the documentary China Blue, if you haven't seen it. thanks again for this info. i wasn't sure where to start.
etsy...love it...i am willing to spend more money on something handmade and made according to my measurements....than buy 10 of something just because it is cheap.....i love the questions being raised here by you and in the comments section...living responsibly....here is how a young couple from where i live are trying to do just this...
http://shopwalkinlove.com/about/
i am looking forward to more of this discussion!!!!
keri
Thanks Heather for getting the wheels turning in our minds! Thanks for asking hard questions and also giving us some good resources to start looking for answers.
I so appreciate what you are a part of in Haiti at Heartline. And its plain to see you're not going to stop being a tool in His Hand just cause you're back in the states for a bit. Blessings to you and your sweet family!
Glad KrispinDanielle shared the link. I love to go check out which companies to support and which I should not.
First, thanks so much for the food for thought this morning and the links.
I'm glad you mentioned Kristof's POV, as that was exactly my thought when reading the first article. I'm actually going into Occupational Health as a career and, by some pretty super-cool heart-changing awesomeness (or crap, depending on the day), I really am seeing the privilege of being in the field as a way to advocate for social justice, especially for women and children. Like everything, there’s nuance, but I hesitate to say “ban all child labor” or “ban sweatshops” because we live in a broken world where those options could definitely be better than the alternative (sex trafficking, etc). I’m starting to try to figure out how to do things like provide work for kids that is less exploitative, etc, until we live in a world where kids don’t have to work.
As far as the clothing issue (and the entire issue of how damaging our donated castoffs are), I do think the main answer is just less is more. Stop buying closets full of junk and buy fewer nice, well-constructed, well-fitted classic pieces (though in today's consumer environment that's frustratingly difficult to find.) Not to mention I find my convictions are often only about as strong as Target's jewelry section. Keep trying, I guess... :-P. I'm glad to see so many people here who are trying!
Oh...and I also meant to ask.
Someone mentioned Etsy. Perish the thought, because I love Etsy, but does anyone know what, if any, oversight sellers on Etsy necessarily have? I've gotten to the point, especially with the increasing amount of sellers who are collectives based outside the US, etc, where I even wonder a little about exploitation of workers even there...
I'm eager to read these articles. The brainier the better. I was discussing these issues with a pastor friend and I remember him stating "well at least they have jobs". And I wanted to punch him in the mouth. So yeah, I should probably read some real insight into this. Thanks for the links.
Not to open another can of worms but even the idea of "living simply so others can simply live" is not as simple (pun intended!) as that.
For our family, going simple and not falling prey to consumerism (let me rephrase that, "trying to not fall prey to consumerism") so that we can give more is our game plan.
And that works at a micro level.
But if the rest of America and the western world were to really live simply and rid ourselves of evil consumerism, the developing, manufacturing world would be annihilated in many ways. It's such a double-edged sword.
The answer/solution is so complex. Demand for goods/services in the Western world is what drives economies in the developing world (among other things of course.)
It was so simple back in the day when all societies were agricultural and there wasn't specialization or comparative advantage economics. Of course, it wasn't as efficient or capable of such scale that we've attained with today's technology/economies, etc.
However, now we're faced with a really difficult quandary: What helps the poor more--to give or to spend???
As Bible-based, Christ-following believers, we must error on the side of giving (especially since we can better direct where such funds go). However, parties on both sides of that debate have solid arguments...
Food for thought.
You do not know me but I stalk your blog and I just wanted to tell you that I have learned SO much from you and have grown tremendously as a person and Christian from reading and dwelling on your words, thoughts, and actions. I think finding your blog was no accident and I am always humbled, amazed, and challenged at the things you post. You are not only impacting the people of Haiti but here in the states as well, that you don't even know. I can't wait to read your book someday, which I hope you write, because you have a captivating way with words that really draws in the reader and the things you have to say are very thought-provoking, educational, and interesting. Thank you to you and your beloved family, what a blessing you are to those that know you and those that don't.
Post a Comment